The films of franco zeffirelli versus baz luhbrmanns version of romeo and juliet two films, both alike in content, set in fair verona, where the directors laid out their scene, one created by franco zeffirelli in 1968 and the other by baz luhbrmann in 1996. They discover their lover is their enemy through decades of family feuds. There have been numerous movies made of romeo and juliet and all of them like all stage plays make some alterations from the script. It has been retold many different times in both written and film text and it is effective and timeless throughout the use of many techniques. Despite the contrast of the two settings, both texts explore the external conflict which stemmed from the family. Apr 17, 2014 last night i watched romeo and juliet 20 film directed by carlo carlei. Most always when movies are compared to the books, the books are better, but not quite in this case. In the play, he does not when juliet is trying to find out who he is, she asks the nurse whats he that follows there, that would not dance. The fighters have guns in the movie, when in the play they have swords. Romeo and juliet movie comparison 2714 words bartleby. Many times the play by william shakespeare is compared to the movie produced by baz luhrman. Romeo doesnt encounter anyone at the crypt and paris is not killed. My world civilization teacher had my class read romeo and juliet when i was fifteen years old. Romeo and juliet in the stage version are a bit spoiled and behave in the same manner that you would expect hormonal teens in medieval times to have behaved, while in the movie romeo leonardo dicaprio gives off the feeling of the poor little rich kid and juliet claire danes is portrayed as this little sheltered princess from the.
While the 1968 classical version of shakespeares romeo and juliet should be appreciated, the. Compare and contrast romeo and juliet play and movie. Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Shakespeare vs luhrmann vs carlei the infamous, tragic deaths of shakespeares starcrossed lovers romeo of montague and juliet capulet have been capturing the hearts of audiences of many centuries, eliciting fairly highbudget adaptations even in the 1990s and 2000s. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3 months new customers receive 15% off your. Long shots showed the dancing, and the camera then followed romeo and juliet s faces. Song choker oi tarate full video movie romeo vs juliet artist ankush,mahi and. In the original play romeo and juliet written by william shakespeare in 1587, throughout the years there have been movies made trying to convey the message that shakespeare had wanted. The project of making a movie on romeo and juliet certainly has some challenges to be encountered. Uh, scott, you say, its romeo and juliet you cant spoil. In the movie the capulets and the montagues are warring families in italy. The dead dagger verona italy pistol verona beach new york in the play. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of romeo and juliet and what it means. Romeo and juliet movie vs book essay example graduateway.
Romeo and juliet movie vs book romeo and juliet, the dramatic love story everyone knows. William shakespeares romeo and juliet is a cherished piece of literature that has been remade into movies many times throughout history. Firstly, in the narrative, the vivid descriptions of the various scenarios are brought out in a several lines of verse. Though romeo and juliet the movie is good, it is still missing many good parts. Dicaprio films are made with the directors different personal opinions based on the original source. First, students fill in the organizer after watching the 1968 version, then as they watch the 1996 film, they contrast the movies. Shakespeares original play, romeo and juliet and luhrmanns appropriated version, both investigate different types of conflict. This exclusive edition of romeo and juliet includes william shakespeares classic tragedy as well as the newly adapted screenplay by the creator of downton abbey, julian fellowes. I remember watching an older version after we finished the book in high. The voices lauren ezzo gave each character were fantastic. Tybalt notices that romeo has crashed the feast and determines to kill him just as romeo catches sight of juliet and falls instantly in love with her. In this deathfilled setting, the movement from love at first sight to the lovers final union in death seems almost inevitable. The films of franco zeffirelli versus baz luhbrmanns version of romeo and juliet 664 words 3 pages. Romeo and juliet movie comparison essay 1055 words 5 pages.
Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet. In both the movie and the play tybalt, juliet s cousin, did not get along with mercutio, romeo s dear friend. Considered as one of the greatest love stories of all time, william shakespeares romeo and juliet is a timeless literary classic and remains perhaps the most appreciated piece of literature in all of history. The 1968 version and the controversial 1996 version give different perspectives of shakespeares famous play. This is brought approximately through every bit love as a cause of force. For this essay, i will discuss some of the contrasts between the original play, and the film. William shakespeares 1590s play romeo and juliet has been adapted to film and television many times. Romeo vs juliet an indobangladesh production in association with jaaz multimedia online distribution qinetic music. A book shows an imaginary world to a reader and gives a reader a platform to create an imaginary world out the story on a book. In romeo and juliet, shakespeare creates a violent world, in which two young people fall in love. What was one of the most memorable moments of romeo and juliet vs.
William shakespeares romeo and juliet is a 1996 american romantic crime tragedy film directed, coproduced, and cowritten by baz luhrmann, co produced. While the 1968 classical version of shakespeares romeo and juliet should be appreciated, the modern version portrays the. Romeo and juliet, the dramatic love story everyone knows. I believe there are many advantages of watching the movie of romeo and juliet over interpreting the book. Jun 08, 2016 scene comparison of romeo and juliets deaths. The fullcolor photo insert of the films cast features hailee steinfeld as juliet, douglas booth as romeo, kodi smitmcphee as benvolio, ed westwick as tybalt, and paul giamatti as friar laurence. Romeo and juliet which romeo and juliet movie is the. Both films do an admirable job of following shakespeares original text, and both films do a great job of showing audiences the doomed love story that is romeo and juliet.
The bbc made some splendid versions of the collective works of shakespeare, of course including romeo and juliet, in the 1980ies and i think they come as close to the actu. The enduring tale of love between two star crossd lovers has been told, acted, and read countless times since its original debut. Love is obviously the dominating and most vital theme of this play. This is a textbook way to film first encounters between lovers. Romeo and juliet movie and book comparison essaysshakespeares romeo and juliet is the most famous love story to date. What are the differences between the book and the movie of. Buy products related to romeo and juliet movie products and see what. Funniest book ive listened to in a while what did you love best about romeo and juliet vs. From that point on, love seems to push the lovers closer to love and violence, not farther from it.
Last night i watched romeo and juliet 20 film directed by carlo carlei. May 05, 2010 another minor difference is that some of mercutios lines in scene 4 were spoken by romeo instead. It is amazing how shakespeares play romeo and juliet written centuries ago can be better than franco zefferellis movie production of romeo and juliet, which had much better technology to work with only decades ago. Romeo and juliet love vs violence essay graduateway. Another minor difference is that some of mercutios lines in scene 4 were spoken by romeo instead. The 20 cinematic adaptation of romeo and juliet got a few things right, but it mostly missed the mark. Baz luhrmann and franco zefirelli are two directors who. Book often times people say that william shakespeare was and still is a legend. Romeo and juliet 20 trailer official movie trailer in hd 1080p starring hailee steinfeld, douglas booth, damian lewis william. Other than the above, act 2 is a fairly faithful treatment of the play. In the book, romeo is told by the nurse that juliet. Unfortunately, juliet, this is not always the case. It ends, as romeo and juliet must, when romeo hears a tragic piece of. Their choices werent necessarily free will because it all boiled down to one option and it was most of.
Tybalt and mercutio were fighting, and it got out of hand just as romeo appeared. I recently read romeo and juliet and i wanted to watch the movie but i. A close study of the relationship between text and film 97807679120. In romeo and juliet, shakespeare creates a violent world, in w.
Difference between romeo and juliet the book and the movie. I dont recall romeo doing acid in the play mercutio was a lot creepier in the movie personal opinion in the movie, juliet wakes up immediately after romeo has taken the poison and they have one last exchange, but that did not happen in the play. Romeo and juliet act v scene iii directors purpose and interpretation does it add or take away. Similarties and differences between romeo and juliet movies shakespeares romeo and juliet is a play based on love, hate, tragedy and sacrifice. Body language and voice tones are a major factor in determining a characters traits. Differences the book vs movie juliet romeo answers. At the time, the words seemed archaic and the plot melodramatic making it more of a chore than an encounter with great literature. Romeo and juliet, though termed as tragedy carries more of shakespeares comedy elements. It tells the story of two starcrossed lovers as they try to find a place in the world together without dealing with the wrath of heir families rivalry. One day, the day that romeo and juliet secretly got married actually. One part is the scene with apothecary when romeo is.
Despite the contrast of the two settings, both texts explore the external conflict which stemmed from the. I think it adds to the original purpose bacause watching it instead of just reading the story really lets you see how they loved each. Romeo goes to the capulet crypt to find juliets body and encounters paris there. Autoplay when autoplay is enabled, a suggested video will automatically play next. Title track full song romeo vs juliet ankush mahiya mahi. Romeo and juliet play and movie comparison film studies essay. Aug 10, 2009 romeo and juliet in the stage version are a bit spoiled and behave in the same manner that you would expect hormonal teens in medieval times to have behaved, while in the movie romeo leonardo dicaprio gives off the feeling of the poor little rich kid and juliet claire danes is portrayed as this little sheltered princess from the. But, youthful obtuseness aside, romeo and juliet is the ideal text to introduce shakespeare. Romeo and juliet by william shakespeare modern language version by andrew matthews and tony ross duration. In act ii, the scene in which mercutio is teasing the nurse was quite the opposite if how i had imagined the scene. Enter romeo, mercutio, benvolio, with five or six other maskers. Jun 18, 2015 romeo and juliet is the classic romance story, and has been adapted over the past centuries in many different forms, but the three that will be focused on will be.
Romeo and juliet movie comparison paper campbell2015. Ive only seen two versions not counting gnomeo and juliet, i think the romeo and juliet death scene at the end was better in the leonardo caprio rather than the one with franco zefferelli. Romeo vs juliet title track ankush mahiya mahi akassh. The whole play is intertwined on the romantic love between romeo and juliet at their first sight. Franco zeffirelli versus baz luhrmann essay place an order famous works of the world literature such as plays by shakespeare and chekhov, novels by dickens, flaubert, austen and others have always attracted movie directors. Romeo and juliet julia essig preuniversity paper didactics english miscellaneous publish your bachelors or masters thesis, dissertation, term paper or essay. In the movie version of romeo and juliet 1996, leonardo dicaprio, the above illustrates this perfectly.
In this play, love supersede other characteristics such as loyalty, emotions etc. Baz luhrmanns energetic adaptation of romeo and juliet, starring leonardo dicaprio and claire danes as the starcrossed lovers. A summary of motifs in william shakespeares romeo and juliet. The passionate love between romeo and juliet is linked from the moment of its inception with death. The tragedy of romeo and juliet shows how innocence and love can become casualties of hatred. Romeo and juliet act 4 scene 3 commentary romeo and juliet a comparecontrast essay comparing the balcony scenes in the movie productions of baz luhrman and franco zeffirelli. Romeo and juliet is the classic romance story, and has been adapted over the past centuries in many different forms, but the three that will be focused on will be. But a lot changed between the original play and the film. Romeo and juliet trailer 20 movie official hd youtube.
Zefirellis romeo and juliet is a true shakespearean movie of all times, as it combines historicism with timelessness of ideas and concepts introduced by shakespeare. The play focuses on romantic love, where romeo and juliet experience love at first sight. What are the differences between the movie and the book titled romeo and juliet. Romeo and juliet movie versus play 612 words 123 help me. William shakespeares romeo and juliet is a 1996 american romantic crime tragedy film directed, coproduced, and cowritten by baz luhrmann, coproduced.
Yes, the play is very good as well as the movie, but the play has its great parts, and its not so great parts as well. The two are family run corporations that are against each other. At the same time, the luhrmanns version, shot as a blockbuster, concentrates upon modern times and can be fully decoded only in the historical context of the late xx century. Depends, in the movie romeo sees juliet next to the nurse, her fiance and her mother. Romeo and juliet movie comparison guide graphic organizer.
This play has been converted into its intended style many times in the past, the earliest version in 1968 was directed by franco zeffirelli, the latest film in 1996 by baz luhrmann. Like this, right away he figured out she was a capulet. Seizing on kenneth branaghs mission to make the bard more accessible to modern audiences, luhrmann produced an mtv shotgun blast to the face. While watching the latest version i thought a lot about the 1968 version which is similar to the 20 film, the 20 film is a. There are many differences between the play and the movie of romeo and juliet. Romeo goes to the capulet crypt to find juliet s body and encounters paris there. As the music quickened, the film used rhythmically equal edits to keep up with the music s pace. For this week im going to compare the iconic play romeo and juliet with the 1996 movie version with leonardo dicaprio and claire danes. We just finished that movie today, and our whole class couldnt help laughing slightly when juliet tried to kill herself. In the 1968 version, romeo first sees juliet on the dance floor. What are five differences between the two film adaptations.
903 503 1065 1268 537 239 767 521 10 660 1335 407 1542 1395 720 696 567 930 535 1290 1430 1089 806 206 37 1462 8 221 947 620 236 313